But …. Sad to say, instead of returning back to Christianity, they only reformed doctrianity. At this point in the story, Bercot focuses for a couple of chapters on this grave mistake. The Protestant reformers reformed the doctrinal lines, but failed to revive simple primitive Christianity. Following on their heels, many commentators and subsequent theologians have simply repeated what they learned from Calvin and Luther. Bercot uses for an example the slightly twisted interpretation that John Calvin gave of 1 Corinthians From there, the author leads the reader into some examples of how twisted historical ideas get perpetuated as fact.
Winding down his story, Bercot comes back to his main point: bearing kingdom fruit vs. Knowledge is not fruit. One can know all sorts of correct things about God. He can even pretend to know more about God than what the Bible actually tells us. But the bottom line on judgment day is not going to be about what we believed, but how much fruit we bore while on planet earth. His point is … well, let me say it this way:. Imagine Jesus sitting on a Galilean hillside, amidst a group of noisy theologians disputing about correct soteriology. David Bercot enters the scene, and begins to ask all the theologians to just sit down.
After asking them—or making them—take a seat, he does not step up on a rock to set everyone straight on the proper view of salvation. Instead, he also meekly takes a seat at the feet of the Teacher. Today we are going to do a thorough review as to how a person gets saved.
- Navigation menu.
- Essentials of Gerontological Nursing.
- Will the Theologians Please Sit Down.
- A Book Review of Systematic Theology by Wayne Grudem.
- The Changing Capital Markets of East Asia (Routledge Studies in the Growth Economies of Asia)!
Sitting in the Gates of Sodom. The Following of Christ. Christianity-It's a Life or Death Matter. Navegation Primitive Christianity home page. Sit down, ye bullies! With a righteous passion that springs from a deep love for the children of the kingdom, Bercot says: In the end, the theological bullies have largely had their way. The judge explains: The witnesses are uniform in testifying that you are an envious and quarrelsome man. You frequently curse in public, and you go about town carrying weapons. You are a thoroughly disagreeable man, justly hated by your fellow townsmen. But, fortunately, you are obviously not one of those detestable heretics, the Anabaptists.
For the life you live is exactly opposite theirs.
A typical week
They would never have you. You are just as you say, an orthodox Christian. There are other people making these arguments with much more nuance actual historians like N. Wright, for example and Bercot needs to take some cues from them. View 1 comment. Apr 05, Andrew rated it really liked it.
Easy to read! His basic viewpoint is that Theologians have squashed Kingdom Christians by making Christianity more about Doctrine than Fruit. He is doing the very thing that he says is dangerous. Feb 18, Greg Dill rated it did not like it. Bercot spends about half the book building a case against theologians, specifically retelling the biblical accounts of Pharisees, Saducees, and the scribes of Jesus' day.
This was quite tedious, repetitive, and really nothing insightful. The remainder of the book are rantings against specific scholars and theologians throughout history whose doctrines Bercot doesn't agree with.
David Bercot – The “Theology” of the Early Christians
Doctrine and theology are bad. We only need to produce good fruit as Jesus taught, not good theology and doctrine. And, Bercot spends about half the book building a case against theologians, specifically retelling the biblical accounts of Pharisees, Saducees, and the scribes of Jesus' day.
And, how does Bercot come to this conclusion? By developing his own theology. This book was a disappointment, not one of Bercot's best. Not recommended. There is a lot of thought-provoking truth in this book that has impacted how I view my role among other believers as well as how much more cautious I am of any man-made doctrine exceeding the word statement of faith that the earliest believers held to.
Just a slight downside is that an instance or two, in his passion on the subject, I think David Bercot reaches a little far with generalizations to support a point. But in overlooking those few instances, I believe his arguments still stan There is a lot of thought-provoking truth in this book that has impacted how I view my role among other believers as well as how much more cautious I am of any man-made doctrine exceeding the word statement of faith that the earliest believers held to.
But in overlooking those few instances, I believe his arguments still stand well-supported. Jun 21, Riley rated it liked it. While I appreciate and agree with the premise of it, I think the author fell into the trap he was trying to avoid. I agree that Christians must bear fruit for the kingdom, but they should not call anyone a theological "bully" just because he or she does not agree with their theological views.
Will the Theologians Please Sit Down by David Bercot (2009, Paperback)
Jan 29, Mark Kolpek rated it it was amazing. Great book David Bercot is a Historian who writes from an intellectually honest perspective. He doesn't say what people want to hear There are some inconvenient truths in the history of Christianity and he is faithful in pointing them out. Great quote - "In the aftermath of Nicea, Jesus' words, "follow me" were no longer the focus of the institutional church.
It was now "study me". And that is the real problem. For "Doctrianity" requires no real relationship wi Great book For "Doctrianity" requires no real relationship with Christ and no fruit.
It requires only a change in our heads, not a change in our hearts. A Pharisee can embrace "Doctrianity". But he will never be able to embrace Christianity without a through change of the heart. Jul 29, Billy rated it it was amazing Shelves: anabaptist-mennonite. Read the book twice. It's worth of my time to re-read it. It challenge me and to stick to what the Gospel really says without filtering or reinterpreting it. I come to realized many follow the doctrine of man. This book should be real and challenge every Christians to reconsider. Apr 23, Lobug rated it it was amazing Shelves: bible-bible-teaching , intelligent-learning.
This is SO Good.
If Faith were a Song, What Would It Sound Like (please, not George Michael) - Theology Corner
You need to read it. For real. READ this book. It is eye-opening. Short, sweet, and to the point. Read it. Jim Bob rated it it was amazing May 20, James Forbes rated it really liked it Oct 23, Jeffrey Mast rated it really liked it Jan 27, David Kinsella rated it it was ok Jul 26, Shawnele rated it it was amazing Jan 28, Joshua rated it really liked it Feb 27, Sandi Applegate rated it it was amazing Nov 30, Errol rated it really liked it Jun 18, Michael R. Amanda rated it it was amazing Mar 26, Kevin Krahn rated it it was amazing Jun 16, Olivia Land rated it it was amazing May 25, Kendal Weaver rated it it was amazing Oct 27, Matthew S.
Related Will the Theologians Please Sit Down
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved